Fall is the season of golden leaves, oversized sweaters, and mugs of steaming tea—and nothing pairs better with that vibe than a cozy book. Whether you’re looking for a charming romance, a heartwarming family saga, or an atmospheric small-town mystery, this list of cozy fall books for 2025 will give you plenty of options to curl up with as the days get cooler.
(Note: This post contains affiliate links. I may earn from qualifying purchases—at no cost to you!)
1. The Pumpkin Spice Cafe by Laurie Gilmore
What could be more fall than a pumpkin spice latte and a small-town romance? This delightful novel follows a woman who inherits a cozy café in a picturesque autumn-soaked village, complete with quirky locals and a slow-burn love story. It’s a hug in book form.
2. The Wishing Game by Meg Shaffer
Full of whimsy and wonder, this novel brings you into a magical world where puzzles, secrets, and second chances collide. Perfect for fans of The House in the Cerulean Sea, this is a cozy and hopeful story for fall evenings.
3. Meet Me at the Lake by Carley Fortune
While Fortune is known for her summery romances, this one leans perfectly into fall—featuring themes of second chances, lakeside nostalgia, and cozy sweater-weather vibes. It’s the perfect romance to read while wrapped in a blanket.
4. The Berry Pickers by Amanda Peters
A tender, heartwarming family story that spans decades, The Berry Pickers will appeal to book club readers who love emotional depth. With its rich descriptions of seasonal change and its strong sense of place, it’s a book that feels like sitting beside a crackling fire.
If you’re planning to read this one with your book club, I created a complete discussion guide for The Berry Pickers—with thought-provoking questions, character breakdowns, themed recipes, and even cocktail pairings. It’s the perfect way to take your reading experience to the next level.
👉 Grab the Book Club Guide here
👉 Get it on Amazon
5. Divine Rivals by Rebecca Ross
For fantasy lovers who still want cozy vibes, this romantic fantasy set against the backdrop of a wartime correspondence is perfect. Full of letters, longing, and lyrical writing, it’s a book to savor on crisp fall nights.
6. In the Shadow of the Greenbrier by Emily Matchar
If you enjoy a Southern Gothic mystery with just the right dose of atmosphere, this novel blends history, secrets, and small-town intrigue. Think cozy mystery meets fall foliage.
7. Remarkably Bright Creatures by Shelby Van Pelt
8. The September House by Carissa Orlando
If you’re looking for a cozy-but-spooky fall read, The September House delivers the perfect balance. This atmospheric novel follows a woman determined to keep her charming Victorian home—even if it’s haunted. With humor, suspense, and just enough gothic flavor, it’s a fantastic choice for readers who want cozy thrills without the gore.
9. Before We Were Strangers by Renée Carlino
This romantic, nostalgic story about lost love and second chances has the same kind of cozy, heart-squeezing vibes that fit perfectly with fall. It’s a great pick for fans of emotional love stories.
10. The Secret Book of Flora Lea by Patti Callahan Henry
For historical fiction fans who want something atmospheric but comforting, this dual-timeline story about lost stories, mystery, and love is the perfect fall read. Cozy, magical, and heartfelt.
Bonus Pick: James by Percival Everett
While not your traditional “cozy” read, James is one of the most talked-about novels of 2025 and a powerful reimagining of Mark Twain’s Adventures of Huckleberry Finn told from Jim’s perspective. Thought-provoking, layered, and deeply human, this book is perfect for readers who want something with more depth to spark meaningful fall conversations.
If you’re reading James with your book club, don’t miss my full book club guide—it includes discussion questions, character lists, Southern-inspired recipes, themed cocktails, and icebreakers to create a truly immersive evening.
Final Thoughts: Cozy Fall Reads 2025
Whether you’re reaching for romance, mystery, or heartwarming family stories, these books will bring all the cozy vibes you crave this autumn. Light a candle, pour yourself a mug of something warm, and let these pages carry you away.
Looking for even more fall book recommendations? Don’t miss my full guide: 25 Must-Read Books for Fall 2025.
